Systematic review of the impact of restrictive wildlife trade measures on conservation of iconic species in southern Africa
5 April 2024
Trade restrictions are often advocated and implemented as measures to protect wild species threatened by overexploitation. However, in some instances, their efficacy has been questioned, notably by governments in the southern African (SADC) region, which tend to favor a sustainable use approach to wildlife management. We conducted a systematic review of published literature guided by the PRISMA process to examine the effectiveness of trade restrictions and directly related control measures in addressing threats to species conservation in the SADC region, with a focus on elephants (Loxodonta sp.), rhinoceroses (Ceratotherium simum, Diceros bicornis), lions (Panthera leo), and pangolins (Manis sp.). We focused in particular on the direct conservation impact of trade restrictions at species or population level, indirect conservation impact at human behavior or attitude level, and socioeconomic impact on rural livelihoods and well-being and on national economies. Research on these topics was uneven and focused strongly on the effects of trade restrictions and law enforcement on crime-related behavior. Research gaps include socioeconomic impacts of trade restrictions, including effects of international restrictions on local livelihoods and consequent secondary conservation impacts, and evaluations of attempts to disrupt criminal networks. Based on the reviewed impact evidence, the effectiveness of international trade restrictions depends on a range of fully aligned measures in countries of origin, transit, and consumption. For example, our results suggest positive ecological short-term but negative or unknown long-term socioeconomic impacts of domestic restrictions. Based on these findings, key policy requirements include more nuanced approaches to incorporate a range of appropriate measures in range, transit, and consumer countries, that focus on capacity development for early detection and apprehension of incursions inside protected areas; measures for constructive engagement with relevant local communities outside protected areas; and future research to improve understanding of the socioeconomic contribution of wildlife.
Hiller, C., & ’t Sas-Rolfes, M. (2024). Systematic review of the impact of restrictive wildlife trade measures on conservation of iconic
species in southern Africa. Conservation Biology, e14262. https://doi.org/10.1111/cobi.14262
Authors
-
Michael ’t Sas-Rolfes
-
Christina Hiller
We support the free flow of information. Please share:
More content
-
Importance of private and communal lands to sustainable conservation of Africa's rhinoceroses
Dr Hayley Clements…2023Research -
-
Collaborative governance models of wild product value chains for conservation and livelihood resilience
Mr Thapelo Brilliant LebopaArticles -
-
-
-
South Africa’s conservation model: why expanding the use of biodiversity to generate money is a good idea
Dr Hayley Clements…Articles -
Natural capital as a potential tool for resolving human-wildlife conflict
Dr Michael MusgraveArticles -
Get updates by email
In a complex and changing world, AWEI generates strategic ideas, conducts independent analysis on wildlife economies, and collaborates with global scholar-practitioners to provide training and expertise for biodiversity conservation, climate resilience, and inclusive economic opportunities in Africa.
Sign up for a quarterly dose of AWEI insights
In a complex and changing world, AWEI generates strategic ideas, conducts independent analysis on wildlife economies, and collaborates with global scholar-practitioners to provide training and expertise for biodiversity conservation, climate resilience, and inclusive economic opportunities in Africa.